PHI001 University College Dublin True Justified Belief Theory of Knowledge Essay

PHI001 University College Dublin True Justified Belief Theory of Knowledge Essay

First paper topic Please turn in your first draft to your TA by October 22nd. Please answer the following question in a 3 page paper (with standard font and margins, double spaced). Two notes: (a) lay things out as clearly as possible and (b) please do not include biographical or historical information and don’t begin your paper with ‘Since the dawn of time…’ Explain the true-justified-belief (TBJ) theory of knowledge we discussed in class (i.e. explain whether the conditions are each necessary, sufficient, sufficient taken together). Then make up your own Gettier case and explain why it is counter-example to the analysis (i.e. explain if it attacks the sufficiency of the conditions, their necessity…) Rubric for paper: Content (60 pts): Opening paragraph (10 pts) 1. Clear statement of the thesis of the paper. (10 points) Description of TBJ: (15 pts) 1. Clear explanation of each condition. (5 pts) 2. Clear evaluation of the necessity/sufficiency of each condition (10 pts.) Your Gettier Example (25 points): 1. Clear statement of assumed principles (10 pts) 2. Clear description of your example. (5 pts) 3. Clear explanation of what the counterexample shows and how it shows it. (10 pts) Conclusion: (10 points) 1. Clear recap and summary of the papers content (10 points) Style (20 pts): 1. The sequence of sentences is coherent and clear. (10 pts) 2. The words are accurate and not used loosely. (10 pts) Grammar and Spelling (10 pts): 1. The paper’s sentences are grammatical and the words are spelled properly. Structure: (10 points): 1. The paper should have a clear introduction (3 points), coherent body (4 points) and conclusion (3 points).